Sunday, October 12, 2008

Najib Unmasked?

Saturday, October 11, 2008

AHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA MONGOLIA!

YEP.....from a most unlikely source, I have been reliably informed.....straight from the Steppes of Inner Mongolia comes this conversation. I was also reliably informed that this was sent to Malaysia Today as a sequel to the letter sent by Altantuya's father. Read on

The following text message correspondence is between YAB Dato' Sri Mohd Najib Tun Abdul Razak, Deputy Prime Minister of Malaysia, and Dato' Shafee Abdullah, a Malaysian lawyer who initially represented Abdul Razak Abdullah Baginda who is on trial for abeting the murder of Mongolian national, Altantuya Shaariibuu.

While it does not answer lingering questions about Najib's alleged past relations with Altantuya, the text messages show clearly Najib's active intereference in the case very early on. The messages highlight Najib's willingness to speak with both members of the Attorney General's Chambers and Inspector General of Police about the case, something that suggests an abuse of executive power.

What is particularly revealing and troubling is that the counsel, Shafee, keeps asking Najib for details indicating some political intervention that may have influenced the case. This observation is strengthened by Najib's message to Shafee on 16 November 2006: "Pls do not say anything to the press today. i will explain later. RB will have to face a tentative charge but all is not lost." This message raises a lot of questions about Najib's role in this case. Why did he mention "tentative" charge and that "all is not lost" for RB (Razak Baginda)? How would Najib know this before Razak was charged? Is there already a deal in place that will see Razak aquitted? These are important questions which will have ramifications not just on this case but far beyond.

The text messages were transmitted between Najib's personal mobile phone (+6012 2143177) and Shafee's mobile phone (+6012 3257052).

Those who seek the truth should challenge Najib and Shafee to deny that this correspondence took place between them. Perhaps a record of the messages still resides in the server of the relevant telecommunications company.

The truth is buried somewhere. Those who know what truly happened hope that the truth has been buried deep with Altantuya. But the funny thing is, the truth always finds its way into the hands of those who fight for justice – sometimes in the most mysterious circumstances......ahaaaaaaaaa!

The SMS-Chat Begins ....

Wednesday 8/11/2006

Najib to Shafee (S2N) Date: 8/11/2006 02:59:31

--> Dato Seri, The Razak Baginda thing is troubling me.Can I help? Salam, Shafee

Najib to Shafee (N2S) Date: 8/11/2006 03:45:05

--> I will speak with u later tonight.

S2N Date: 8/11/2006 03:45:31

--> Thank you

S2N Date: 8/11/2006 06:28:56

--> Met the investigating officer today.Position is serious for RB.The 3 are highly implicated.RB's case can be fought.There are redeeming features for him.But we need to meet Dato Seri as there are other looming issues at large.But not to worry. Salam > Shafee

N2S Date: 8/11/2006 21:06:11

--> I have spoken to IGP. U can represent n meet RB in court.

Thursday 9/11/2006

N2S Date: 9/11/2006 12:45:30

--> If RB's remand is upto Sunday, does it mean that he has to be charged by Fri or be released? i hope it is looking better for him.

S2N Date: 9/11/2006 13:11:23

--> 3 things can happen.Firstly, they can ask for more time for detention.We will resist.Second,they have to release him by Friday or thirdly charge him by Friday.Police took him to his office for document search.Nothing incriminating found.Now they are recording stmt from him.Later search in house.Under control so far Dato Seri. Salam, shafee

S2N Date: 9/11/2006 14:09:03

--> Dato Seri, Re RB need to meet up with you today. shafee

N2S Date: 9/11/2006 14:17:47

--> 630 pm at my house in PJaya this evening.

S2N Date: 9/11/2006 14:18:21

--> Thank you

Friday 10/11/2006

N2S Date: 10/11/2006 15:14:31

--> Any news about RB ?

S2N Date: 10/11/2006 15:19:40

--> Dato Seri, Negotiating for conditional release.If not police need 2 or 3 more days extention.I suspect its an exercise in public relation as they do not want public to think a VIP was given an easier time.Being a vip under these conditions is a liability.Otherwise we are on track according to plan. Salam, Shafee

N2S Date: 10/11/2006 15:27:01

--> Thanks, he is very stressful according to his wife n would be a huge help if he could get a conditional release latest by sun.

N2S Date: 10/11/2006 21:35:52

--> Saw the news on tv. RB was sent for DNA. Not sure it was neccessary.

S2N Date: 10/11/2006 21:40:19

--> Unnessasary.But I think its on his lung infection.He has just been sent again to HUKM.Will know more later from inside contacts.

Saturday 11/11/2006

S2N Date: 11/11/2006 03:17:56

--> Dato Seri, I was at ghkl ccu 4th floor.RB was admitted due to lung infection:mild pneumonia and asthmatic.This was the pain he was suffering in the chest and unexplained coughing for months.He is under an able physician Dato Dr Jeyaindran Sinnadurai(head of Dept of Medicine)Its good he is resting there than in the lockup.Dna was done to eliminate that he was at scene of crime(paternity can be ruled out as well).Need to see Dato Seri on some concerns. Salam. Shafee

N2S Date: 11/11/2006 08:54:17

--> ANy chance of a release by sun ?

S2N Date: 11/11/2006 08:58:14

--> Police should release him by then except that I think the police is disturbeb by Media and public pressure.Other factors need be coomunicated to Dato Seri in person. Investigation wise we are on track for release.

S2N Date: 11/11/2006 09:26:52

--> It is clear that the Police will ask for extention t'row.I will resist strongly in view of the fact that the last few days investigation on RB have completed investigations that require RB's presence in custody.Secondly, from yesterday the Police has done nothing much with him except to do the dna.Thirdly, I am concerned with the Police carelessness yesterday in allowing the 3 other suspects to be freely mixing and therefore tainting their subsequent stmnts as they could be 'group coached'.But it also show Police no longer need to isolate the suspects.Even RB was handcuffed to the C/I. Salam . Shafee

N2S Date: 11/11/2006 11:46:48

--> I Can see u today at my Taman duta hse at 6 pm.

S2N Date: 11/11/2006 11:59:08

--> OK Dato Seri.Insyaallah I will be there.

Sunday 12/11/2006

S2N Date: 12/11/2006 13:53:41

--> 2 days extention to Tuesday.They must release him by then maybe conditionally.Police asked for full 14days.He has message.

S2N Date: 12/11/2006 14:06:23

--> Will give Dato Seri in a while

S2N Date: 12/11/2006 15:10:17

--> 0320949418

Monday 13/11/2006

S2N Date: 13/11/2006 15:53:36

--> Am in his office now.Another search. AG will be unwilling to charge and lose a case yet again.It is agood idea to suggest to AG to hood on and let investigtion proceed with Razak Released on Bond.

N2S Tel: 60122143177 Date: 13/11/2006 16:23:29

--> How was the search ?

S2N Date: 13/11/2006 16:25:56

--> We provided them everything,including old pda and note books and a couple of bills.Nothing incriminating.

Wednesday 15/11/2006

S2N Date: 15/11/2006 13:21:32

--> Things going as expected.2 male officer charged for murder in common intention.Razak's name not in. Lady officer released but rearrested under Emergency Ordinance to be used as Crown witness(exactly as predicted). I am expecting RB to be released on Bond.4 of my lawyers are watching brief the proceedings in the murder case.Rb matter prob t'row. Pl call. Shafee Ps coming back now from Taipei.

N2S Date: 15/11/2006 23:31:09

--> So hopefully he will be released tmrw?

S2N Date: 15/11/2006 23:34:38

--> Dato Seri, I am driving up from S'pore ,no more flight to KL tonight.Hope for th best.Any indication? Shafee

N2S Date: 15/11/2006 23:36:52

--> Not heard anything untoward yet.

Thursday 16/11/2006

S2N Date: 16/11/2006 10:52:43

--> Anything Dato Seri? I am already in Court.

N2S Date: 16/11/2006 10:53:50

--> Pls do not say anything to the press today. i will explain later. RB will have to face a tentative charge but all is not lost.

S2N Date: 16/11/2006 10:54:30

--> OK, TQ

Friday 17/11/2006

S2N Date: 17/11/2006 10:50:30

--> Dato Seri, Its important you speak toYusoff Zainal Abidin as he knows the law a lot better in the Chambers.I am confident he is concerned with the negligible evidence agst Razak.The Raja Mahani and Tengku Ariston cases ought to be the guiding critera for AG.They cannot afford another scandallous loss by the Prosecution as in Norita, Ariston,Dato Balwant etc.

N2S Date: 17/11/2006 11:39:46

--> OK will try. Meanwhile try to console the wife. She is hysterical.

S2N Date: 17/11/2006 11:41:29

--> I know Dato Seri.I will do everything I can.Salam, Shafee

S2N Date: 17/11/2006 12:57:49

--> Dato Seri, Razak has not been sent to Hospital.He is clearly not well.He is refusing to take Prison's medicine for fear of sabourtage.The chief Physician of GHKL Dato Dr Jaya Sinnadurai is shocked that they have not brought Razak back to GHKL.I have spoken to Haji Darussalam,Sg Buloh's Prison Director.Can You sound this to Dato Radzi Shek Ahmad?Need to see you of s'thing that I think had happened that led to her death.Utterly shocking if I am right. Shafee

S2N Date: 17/11/2006 15:45:34

--> Dato Seri, I am at Sg Buloh Prison.I have organised Razak to be in HUKL,He is on his way there now. The Pengarah Hj Darussallam and deputy Supt Gunasegaran very helpful. Shafee

N2S Date: 17/11/2006 21:27:02

--> My regards to him. He Is always in my thought.

S2N Date: 17/11/2006 21:34:44

--> Will tell him

Sunday 19/11/2006

S2N Date: 19/11/2006 16:25:08

--> Dato Seri, I need Dsp Musa ,your ADc to call me to clarify a point.He is not answering Shafee

Monday 20/11/2006

S2N Date: 20/11/2006 13:02:33

--> Any developement Dato Seri? Shafee

N2S Date: 20/11/2006 14:30:20

--> Not yet.

S2N Date: 20/11/2006 14:30:38

--> Thank you

S2N Date: 20/11/2006 21:05:17

--> Dato Seri.Razak is being transfered to Sg. Buloh t'row.Can Dr. Jaya do anything?

N2S Date: 20/11/2006 23:04:50

--> When is he being transffered?

S2N Date: 20/11/2006 23:05:48

--> T'row

N2S Date: 20/11/2006 23:07:01

--> What time?

S2N Date: 20/11/2006 23:08:01

--> Probably late morning

Thursday 23/11/2006

N2S Tel: 60122143177 Date: 23/11/2006 13:46:51

--> Your message read" Najib released on personal bond!".

S2N Date: 23/11/2006 13:50:00

--> Razak released on Bail of 1 million. On personal bond undertaking. Shafee?I am terribly sorry for that mistake.Whole night tak tidur preparing. My profuse apologies Sir. salam. shafee

N2S Date: 23/11/2006 14:00:25

--> ALhamdullillah , at least he is on bail.Big relief for him n family.

S2N Date: 23/11/2006 14:02:02

--> Dato, I need to brief you urgently b4 you speak to him.Shafee

N2S Date: 23/11/2006 14:12:32

--> OK but not intending to speak to him as yet.

Saturday 2/12/2006

S2N Date: 2/12/2006 18:59:15

--> Dato Seri, Got some info that are troubling.Quite serious.Are you in Taman Duta?Can we meet? Salam, Shafee

... those who know more, please come forward!




pic by bodohland

THIS TOO COULD BE INTERESTING READING.

Sarawak BN ADUNs & MPs Are Blind, Deaf & Dumb



Open Email to Sarawak BN ADUNs and MPs

Unfortunately I am not able to send this open email to most of the Sarawak BN ADUNs as their email addresses could not be found on the Sarawak State Assembly site. I am not sure why as in this modern time, all ADUNS must be able to communicate with and accessible by email. I hope they are not living in the Sarawak jungles like our fellow Penans.

I have not been able to send this open email to some Sarawak BN MPs as their email addresses are also not available on the Malaysian Parliament web site. I am not sure why, either they do not wish people to contact them or they do not know how to use the Internet.

Dear Sarawak BN ADUNs and MPs, do you all serve the people of Sarawak or yourself, your families, relatives and your friends ?

When you came into office, you all swore on the Bible or the Koran that you would serve the people of Sarawak, although there was no mention that you should serve yourself, your families, your relatives and your friends. But common sense will tell you all that Corruption is a crime in Malaysia. Yet Corruption is so rampant in Sarawak, especially among the BN politicians.

However, since you came into office, it has been shown that many of you serve only yourselves, your families, your relatives and your friends, and have neglected the Sarawak people at large. Taib's "Politics of Development" has only benefited a handful of people, especially those related to the BN politicians and State ministers. This is not lies, but facts.

Many reports have been published in the media and many other sources, locally in Malaysia and overseas, including the Registrar of Companies, Bursa Malaysia, web sites of companies such as CMs Bhd., the records on Land & Survey, etc etc. Kyoto News and Tribune Pontianak, that show many of you, your families, your relatives and your friends and those close to you, own lands given by the State Government, shares in various companies owning lands given by Sarawak Givernemnt, oil palm plantations and timber concessions and timber related industries, and contracts awarded by the state government to various parties related to the ministers or BN politicians without any tender and bids being called, in contradiction to the Government's tendering and procurement procedures.

Although I believe that some of you are not involved in any of these and do not have any interests at all in these instances of conflict of interests situation, however, you choose to keep quiet and have not voiced out against what is definitely wrong practised by the state government led by CM.

I wonder whether you all have any conscience at all and how you can tolerate this sort of corruption and cronyism going on in the state. You choose to turn a blind eye to what has been happening in the last 25 years on the actions by the state government that things are getting from bad to worst.

By not voicing out against what is clearly wrongful and illegal acts by the state government and its ministers, you are allowing those ADUNs and MPs committing the wrongs which they swore not to do and you are not serving the people of Sarawak protecting their interests and the interests of their next generations.

I give below some of the information which I know you already knew long time ago. Maybe each time you pretend that you do not know or choose not to believe them.

These are not stories made up by anyone, not lies told by local and overseas media or persons, but HARD facts.

* How did our CM justify the fact that his immediate families and relatives managed to purchase so much shares in CMS ? Did our CM inherit a lot of riches from his parents or someone else ? We all know that he was brought up by a poor family in Sarawak and did not have much money at all.

Name of Shareholder No. of Ordinary Shares Held % of Issued Capital

Majaharta Sdn Bhd 44,925,102 13.64
Lejla Taib 37,000,000 11.23
Sulaiman Taib 29,465,085 8.94
Mahmud Taib 23,400,085 7.10
Hanifah Hajar Taib 705,000 0.21

Records also show that Hanifah Hajar Taib, Ahmad Alwee Alsree and Jamilah Hamidah Taib own shares in Majaharta Sdn Bhd.

* Contracts were awarded by the state government to CMS (substantially owned and controlled by Taib's family) for the construction of the new DUN building. CMS then subcontracted to Bina Puri (a subsidiary of a Malaysian listed company) for a sum which is RM75 million less than the awarded price. Records also show that contracts worth more than RM1 billion were also awarded to CMS for road maintenance in Sarawak, and another worth more than RM 1 billion for construction of 500 bridges was awarded to Titanium Management Berhad who is owned by Taib's son and his friend, Chris. Apparently the contract sum has been exceeded before all the bridges have been built.

* Many hundreds of thousands of state (and maybe NCR) lands have been given away by the state to the CM's family members, relatives, friends and companies known to be controlled by the CM's family or relatives and friends.cronies at very low prices and they sold some to the real plantation companies at 20 to 30 times the prices which they pay the state government. In many cases, they sell the shares in the companies which they own such that they are not subject to income taxes in Malaysia.

*

One of the local NGO officials involved, Peter John Jaban, in a statement today, dared Jabu to reveal the real reason behind his refusal to allow the state government agency to meet up with the NGO officials. Jaban said the deputy chief minister's cancellation of the briefing at the last minute, when the officials were already in Salcra headquarters, had nothing to do with him contesting as a candidate against Jabu.

"When Jabu refused to allow officials of Salcra to meet us, he should explain the real reasons behind his decision," Jaban said.

He believed it had more to do with what he (Jaban) tried to expose during the election campaign period - the involvement of a plantation company, Durafarm Sdn Bhd, in a land tussle with NCR landowners in Betong.

kampung chang sungai gepai encroachment 300307 excavator One of the directors and major shareholders in the company is Robert Lawson Chuat, Bukit Sabah state assemblyperson and Jabu's nephew.

Durafarm, which is controlled by a Sibu-based timber and plantation company, has more than 6,000 hectares plantation land allocated to it by the state government.

Jaban said he had documentary evidence to prove this fact and also to show that two other companies - Zainoon Shipping Sdn Bhd and Biogift Sdn Bhd of which Jabu's son Gerald Rentap is director and major shareholder - have businesses dealing in transportation and fertilisers linked to Salcra.

Salcra is a major NCR land developer, with an estimated total acreage of 20,234 hectares in various locations. Jahan however noted that Salra was a genuine land developer, which sincerely aimed to enhance the economic status of natives in the state.

WTK group also owns two oil-mills with a total production capacity of 90 tonne of FFB per hour. To cope with the increasing production of FFB within our group as well as to provide services to other small holders, a new 60-tonne palm oil mill will be operational by the 1st quarter of Year 2004. At present, the annual total production of FFB is 400,000 tonne. In coming years, our production is expected to be better with the larger matured acreage. WTK's palm oil operations have contributed substantial cash flow to the group over the years. To synergise and consistent with the group expansion programme and down stream development for higher-value addition of palm oil products, WTK group is planning to move into palm oil refinery in the near future. Our group's determination and intense focus in monitoring cost efficiency and increase productivity to ensure that all operations are run with reduced production cost and improved profit contribution. Our group's is now beginning to reap the fruits of its aggressive ventures into oil-palm sector over the past few years.

To enquire, please contact:

Mr Neil Wong Hou Lianq
Chief Operating Officer - Agribusiness (Oil Palm)

Ms Patricia Lee
BHB Sdn Bhd (26303-V)
Utahol Sdn Bhd (323032-T)
Oxford Glory Sdn Bhd (T.370774-W)
Southwind Plantation Sdn Bhd (T197239-W)
Tajang Laing Holdings Sdn Bhd (47605-V)
Medan Mestika Sdn Bhd (466200-U)
Imbok Enterprise Sdn Bhd (151435-P)

Ms Helen Loh
Suajaya Mahir Crop Sdn Bhd (426032-K)
Durafarm Sdn Bhd (461165-M)
Harvard Master Sdn. Bhd. (397883-D)
WTK Oil Mill Sdn Bhd (274278-P)

* See attached list of lands given away by the state government to various people

* No action has been taken on various corruption reports lodged with ACA for corruptions against Sarawak Minister/s :

Taib implicated in Indon timber scam

Aug 23, 08 3:55pm

Indonesian logs are being illegally imported into Sarawak and re-exported as local timber to other countries, including China, Taiwan and Japan, according to an Indonesian newspaper report.

In the Aug 14 edition of the Tribun Pontianak, the Pontianak-based Indonesian language daily also implicated chief minister Abdul Taib Mahmud and Hardwood Sdn Bhd, a wholly-owned unit of state agency Sarawak Timber Industry Development Corporation (STIDC).

"The good name of the chief minister and that of the government-owned company have been marred by the report," Sarawak PKR chief Dominique Ng told Malaysiakini.

Ng said PKR will lodge a report with the Anti Corruption Agency on the matter. According to him,the Tribun Pontianak report was serious enough towarrant immediate investigation by the authorities here, especially since Indonesia and Malaysia have an existing agreement prohibiting the illegal export of logs.

"Let the relevant authorities carry out an immediate and thorough investigation," said Ng, who is also assembly person for Padungan.

The front-page news report was accompanied by a chart detailing how logs were being transported illegally from the forests in Ketapang and how they were being shipped out of West Kalimantan to two places. The names of some middlemen purportedly involved in the scam were also mentioned.

According to the report, several individuals were charged in an Indonesian court for complicity in illegal timber trade, including the forest controller for the area, a M Darwis. The report said Darwis admitted to receiving bribe money from the individuals in exchange for allowing the logs to be illegally taken out of Ketapang.

The forest controller told the court the bribe money amounted to between Rp 10 million and Rp 40 million for each shipment of between 800 and 1,000 cubic metres of timber.About 30 shipments of illegal logs worth some Rp2.16 trillion(about RM750,000) were being taken out either by land or sea across to the East Malaysian state every month.

NGOs go undercover

An Indonesian-based NGO together with a UK-based NGO investigating the illegal timber trade in Indonesia had gone undercover to Sarawak, where they traced the eventual destination of the logs.

The name of Harwood Sdn Bhd was implicated, although Tribun Pontianak erroneously reported the firm was owned by 'the governor of Sarawak' Abdul Taib Mahmud.The news report also highlighted a dialogue the European Commission had in Kuching with various stake-holders and NGOs on issues of the legality of the timber being exported to Europe.

The legality issue is tied to, among other things, the sources of the timber and respect for the rights of indigenous groups living on the land from which the timber is extracted.Malaysiakini understands some of the logs end up being processed by local industries, which would otherwise face a shortage because of an increase in manufacturing activities and also because Sarawak still allowed the export of timber. Up to 40 percent of the total annual production of round logs is exportable.

Timber is one of Sarawak's main earners accounting for several billions of ringgits in export revenue each year.

Taib family's CMS to benefit from dam
Sep 30, 08 11:30am

Who will foot the bill for the resettlement of those affected by the new RM3 billion Murum dam?

MCPX

''Is it Sarawak Energy (Berhad) or will it be passed on directly to the state government and hence the taxpayer,'' asked one Sarawak-based activist, who declined to be identified.

In the case of Bakun, the mega-dam in central Sarawak which is still under construction, compensation to indigenous people and resettlement cost the Sarawak and federal governments over RM876 million.

But there are still Bakun residents who have not received compensation even though they left the Bakun area 10 years ago,'' noted the auditor-general in his 2007 annual report.

Sarawak Energy Berhad (SEB), which is 65 percent owned by the Sarawak state government, will fund the Murum dam. It was reported in June that SEB would issue bonds to finance the project.

SEB has been in negotiations with infrastructure firm Cahaya Mata Sarawak (CMS) and the multinational Rio Tinto Alcan to supply 900-1,200MW of electricity to power a huge smelter. A power purchase agreement was supposed to have been signed by Aug 31, and there has been no news since.

Both CMS and Rio Tinto are in a consortium, the Sarawak Aluminium Company (Salco), to build the US$2 billion aluminium smelter with an initial annual capacity of 550,000 tonnes, which could later be expanded to 1.5 million tonnes. The smelter is located in the Similajau area of Sarawak, not far from the proposed Murum and Bakun dams.

Rio Tinto Alcan, which has a 60 percent stake in Salco, owns bauxite mines, alumina refineries and aluminium smelters around the world.

CMS, a listed infrastructure firm controlled by Sarawak Chief Minister Taib Mahmud's family, is a major producer and supplier of steel, cement and other construction materials in the state. Taib has been chief minister of Sarawak for more than 25 years.

According to the firm's 2007 annual report, the substantial shareholders of CMS are the chief minister's daughters, Jamilah Hamidah and Hanifah Hajar, son-in-law Syed Ahmad Alwee Alsree, and family concern Majaharta Sdn Bhd, each with a 14 percent stake.

Taib's wife Laila has an 11 percent stake while sons, Sulaiman Abdul Rahman and Mahmud Abu Bekir, own 9 percent each.

Taib's brother-in-law, Aziz Husain, on the other hand, happens to be managing director of SEB.

Why the need of so many dams?

Sarawak plans to lure such energy-hungry industries by providing an abundant supply of cheap electricity within the 320-km long Sarawak Corridor of Renewable Energy (Score), an economic development region, managed by the state, where abundant power would be supplied to energy-intensive private industries.

Score, launched by Prime Minister Abdullah Ahmad Badawi in February 2008, aims to tap into the state's 20,000MW hydropower potential by building even more dams in the longer term.

Sarawak's current installed capacity is just 980MW, adequate for its current needs of about 750MW, but it aims to expand its hydro capacity to 7,000MW or more over the next decade by building a string of 12 dams along the various rivers in the state.

hydropower projects in sarawak 2008 2020 murum

While smelters could create jobs and contribute to GDP, the funding for the dams required to supply cheap electricity will have to be raised by the state or borrowed from public pension funds (as in the case of Bakun).

And while indigenous communities are displaced, many foreign workers will have to be brought in for the construction of the dams. And then there are the environmental costs.

''Will that justify building Murum at a probable estimated cost of RM3 billion, with likely cost overruns to RM5 billion?'' asked a Sarawak-based academic, who declined to be identified.

In the case of Bakun, ''cost over-runs of RM708 million were approved by the Finance Ministry even though the contract was for a fixed lump sum with all risks to be borne by the main contractor (a consortium of private Malaysian companies and China interests),'' chided the auditor-general in his report.

Sarawak Hidro, the Bakun dam developer, has outstanding borrowings (as at end-2007) of RM3.4 billion. It had received RM3 billion from a state-managed workers' pension fund, the Employees' Provident Fund (EPF) in 2007, and RM400 million from a state-owned pension trust fund in 2002.

The EPF loan is guaranteed by the federal government. The federal government had also allocated RM1.8 billion for the project between 1997 and 2004. Sarawak Hidro has already spent RM4 billion on the project.

Natives: Better bomb us now

So is Murum really necessary?

''For energy needs in Sarawak, we don't need the Murum, because Bakun is more than enough to supply the state's needs,'' says Raymond Abin of the Borneo Resource Institute (Brimas). ''Of course, (much of) this will not go to the really rural areas but will supply industry's needs."

The impression among many sceptics is that these are all self-serving projects," said another senior academic in a Sarawak-based university, carefully weighing his words while requesting anonymity.

All these funds are not helping the most affected communities like the Penan.

''This is not development for the Penan. This is not assisting the Penan,'' says Weng, a Penan whose home will be submerged. ''This is killing the Penan. As our old headman said before, better bomb us now than 'kill' us slowly!''

Yesterday: Sarawak begins work on new RM3 bil dam

Taib Mahmud & Family's Dirty Smelter Deals
Wednesday, May 7, 2008

Sarawak will soon have what reports say could be one of the world's largest aluminium smelters:

Global miner Rio Tinto Ltd. and Malaysian conglomerate Cahya Mata Sarawak signed a pact Tuesday to jointly build an aluminum smelter in Malaysia's eastern state of Sarawak.

Production from the smelting plant on Borneo island will begin in the fourth quarter of 2010 with an initial annual output of 550,000 metric tons, rising to 1.5 million tons over time, the companies said in a statement.

Under the agreement, the companies will undertake a feasibility study to be completed in 18 months, the statement said.

Rio will hold a 60 percent stake in the venture to be known as Sarawak Aluminium Company. The remaining 40 percent will be owned by Cahya Mata, in which the family of Sarawak Chief Minister Abdul Taib Mahmud is a key shareholder.

The smelter will be powered by the 2,400-megawatt Bakun hydroelectric dam due to be completed by 2010.

The company says the plant will create thousands of jobs and boost the Malaysian economy.

Sure, although I got a feeling that many of those jobs will be taken up by migrant workers.

But that's not what worries me most.

In case you didn't know, Rio Tinto is not exactly the world's most popular company, and aluminium smelting is not exactly an activity that is benign to human health and the environment.

In fact, aluminium smelting consumes humongous amounts of energy:

Besides using one-fifth of the Queensland state's electricity, around the world, Rio Tinto smelters use one-sixth of New Zealand's power, a quarter of Tasmania's and a tenth of Wales's

Loads of power, large tracts of land, and cheap labour — Sarawak is just the sort of place that Rio Tinto likes.

There's also one more fact that makes it and places like the Middle East attractive locations for aluminium smelting:

Why so? It's a no-brainer. As the company's head of climate change told me when I asked about the new geography of aluminium smelting: "Abu Dhabi is outside the Kyoto protocol."

Malaysia is a signatory, but "as a developing country, Malaysia has no quantitative commitments under the Kyoto Protocol at present", according to the Centre for Environment, Technology and Development Malaysia.

Wonderful, eh?

That's not all. Sarawak chief minister Taib Mahmud says there's room for two smelters.

People of Sarawak, enjoy your "development", Barisan Nasional-style.

BUT MAYBE there's a way out of this yet.

Is Sarawak a signatory of the Islam Hadhari convention?

Because if it is, Sarawakians can invoke Principle #9, which is "safeguarding the environment". MERDEKA!

Comment:

Environ 15 August 2007 @ 3:17 pm

Rio Tinto evades questions on Bougainville at AGM
Friday 5th May 2006

Rio Tinto evades questions on Panguna at AGM (and affirms riverine waste dumping as 'best practise' at the Freeport mine)

Rio Tinto directors evaded questions over whether they would take responsibility for the legacy of environmental problems at the Panguna mine on Bougainville Island, and failed to make any clear commitments that they would engage the Indigenous traditional landowners before continuing discussions over resumption of the operations. While they said they had "no plans' to reopen the mine, they did admit that discussion where taking place amongst some stakeholders.

The issue is highly charged, given the tens of thousands of lives lost when the environmental problems caused by riverine waste dumping and the exclusion of traditional landowners concerns shut down the mine and lead to a civil war. There remains significant sentiments on the island that the project should never be reopened, and legitimate concerns that failing to respond to community sensitivities could be a receipe for disaster.

Moses Havini, the International representative for Bougainville for the last fifteen years who attended the A.G.M in Melbourne sought commitments for independent environmental studies and acknowledgement of the rights of traditional owners before discussions on the mine could continue, and sought commitments that Rio Tinto would halt any talks until traditional landowners impacted by the mine would be included as equal participants.

Mr. Havini is concerned that the essential commitments and necessary discussions with local people are not taking place.

"Mining companies must radically change their terms of agreement with traditional landowners in the Pacific region. Firstly, further independent environmental impact studies must be carried out before any decisions are made regarding mining in Panguna, or elsewhere. Secondly, the traditional landowners should be given a fair share of any mining venture, and their right to free, prior and informed consent for any developments respected. Thirdly, mining companies in the Pacific must not pump their tailings any more into the river systems or into the seas. Fourthly, the Panguna Landowners Association are still to be fully compensated including arrears by Bougainville Copper Limited, and Fifthly, RTZ must fully commit itself to a full environmental cleanup of toxic materials and chemicals strewn from the Panguna Copper mine to the Port of Loloho" Mr. Havini said.

Rio Tinto said that they were continuing discussions with the other shareholders in the mine and the provincial and P.N.G. national government, but made no commitment that the traditional landowners would be included in these discussions.

With customary landownership by traditional indigenous owners the primary form of landholding across Papua New Guinea and the recent approval of a Constitution for Bougainville that firmly places the ownership of land and resources with the people, Rio's top down approach, and the question of ownership of the lease itself is unresolved and set to inflame issues.

"One would have hoped that previous experiences would have taught the company that customary indigenous landowners whose lands will be impacted need to be included from day one of any discussions, and their rights to exercise free, prior informed consent over projects on their land acknowledged." stated Techa Beaumont of the Mineral Policy Institute. " Rio Tinto has done as much in Australia at mine such as Jabiluka, so why will they not do the same in our neighbouring countries? In the context of what people of Bougainville have suffered as a result of Rio Tinto's former operations, any other approach shows a reckless disregard for the suffering and loss of life that has occurred."

Rio Tinto was also under fire for its involvement in the Freeport mine.

"Freeport is contributing to the suffering in West Papua because it funds the Indonesian government and military", West Papuan refugee Herman Wanggai told the meeting.

"You can't separate what the mine is doing from the political situation in West Papua. It is directly linked to the human rights problems."

Claims about the environmental impact of tailings released into the river system, and ongoing breaches of environmental laws were also raised following the release of a report into the mine this week by Indonesian environmental NGO WALHI.

Rio Tinto defended the contraversial practice, which BHP Billiton ruled out ever using again after admitting the environmental disaster it caused at the Ok Tedi mine. Chairman Paul Skinner continued to defend its use at Freeport, saying that the company believed its use was best practice for the operation. He did concede however that they would not consider utilizing it again in any proposal to reopen the Panguna operation.

"Rio's defense of riverine tailings disposal at Freeport as an example of 'best practice' is disturbing," Minerals Policy Institute Executive Director Techa Beaumont said.

Skinner also refused to answer questions on when the mine would stop breaching Indonesia's environmental regulations. The breaches led to the Indonesian environment ministry calling on the company to comply with Indonesian laws earlier this year. Mr Witoelar was reported by Reuters news service in April as saying "If they don't do it (points necessary to comply) then we would give a warning. If they still don't do it then we will bring them to court.

For more information, please contact:

Techa Beaumont, Executive Director, Mineral Policy Institute 0409 318 406

Moses Havini, International Representative of the Bougainville Autonomous Government: 0409226428
Monday September 1, 2008
A-G's report: Costly delay on Bakun dam project

KUALA LUMPUR: Finance Ministry Inc and Sarawak Hidro Sdn Bhd (SHSB) were reminded to ensure that contractors complete work within time for the Bakun project to avoid further delay and cost increases, as RM3.91bil had been spent as of last year for the construction of the dam.

The initial cost of the dam was RM4.5bil, but SHSB had already borrowed RM5.2bil from 2002 to 2007 for the project.

The Auditor-General's Report for 2007 said the main dam, scheduled for completion last September, was given an extension till June 2010 because of 16 work order modifications issued by SHSB.

The Finance Ministry also approved an additional RM708mil for the Malaysia-China Hydro Joint Venture (MCHJV), a consortium of seven companies formed to build the main dam and other related work.

It said the failure of MCHJV to complete work on time affected progress of mechanical-electro work, resulting in the contractor, Alstom Power Asia Pacific Sdn Bhd, seeking compensation of RM161.34mil, while BEM1-C Contract Consortium, another contractor for the mechanical-electro work, asked for RM349.46mil in compensation.

So far, the report said SHSB had paid Alstom Power Asia Pacific Sdn Bhd RM80mil and BEM1-C Contract Consortium RM20mil.

The report also said up to November 2007, SHSB had paid BEM 1-C Contract Consortium RM317.64mil in deposit and progress payment although it had yet to sign a contract with SHSB.

"The absence of a contract may cause BEM1-C Contract not being liable if things go wrong," it said.

In the reply on points raised in the report, it said the contract had yet to be signed as disputes on clauses, including currency of payment, had yet to be sorted out.

It also said that SHSB and the Government had agreed to pay BEM1-C Contract RM145mil in compensation due to delay caused by MCHJV.

The AG's report said the delay in implementing the Bakun project was also caused by several changes in the target power generation capacity.

Meanwhile, 10 years after Bakun residents left their homes to make way for the dam, some of them have yet to receive full compensation for the relocation, said the report.

As of December last year, RM46.28mil had yet to be paid out as compensation.

The delay was due to families refusing to accept the compensation sum decided by the Sarawak Government.


Monday September 1, 2008

Dam developer lost RM9mil for not sticking to contract

KUALA LUMPUR: The failure of Sarawak Hidro Sdn Bhd (SHSB) to take advantage of a lower ringgit-US dollar exchange rate for payment to one of its Bakun dam contractors caused it RM9.02mil.

The 2007 Auditor-General's report said that the sum could have been saved had the progressive payments from SHSB to contractor Malaysia China Hydro Joint Venture been converted to US dollars as stated in the contract.

The report showed that the first 15 progressive payments were converted from ringgit to a sum of US$26.43mil as stated in the contract and this had helped to save the company RM0.87mil due to a weaker US dollar.

The contract exchange rate was fixed at US$1 to RM3.826, but the prevailing rate at the times of payment was US$1 to RM3.389-RM3.816.

However, subsequent progressive payments were not converted and payment for a sum of US$44.14mil was made in ringgit using the fixed contract exchange rate.

This meant that Sarawak Hidro paid RM9.02mil more, when it could have paid only RM159.88mil if it had used the lower prevailing exchange rate.

The Auditor-General was of the view that Sarawak Hidro should have complied with the agreement in the contract to pay in US dollars.

In its reply, Sarawak Hidro said Malaysia China Hidro had applied to Sarawak Hidro to pay in ringgit although it was stated in the contract that 27.46% of the payment to be made in US dollars.

It said the matter was brought up in the board of directors' meeting on May 31, 2005, and the board decided to defer the payment until the pegging of the ringgit was lifted.

Following the lifting of the peg, Sarawak Hidro made the progressive payments in ringgit starting Sept 2005.

Sarawak Hidro, formed in 2000, was previously named Bakun Hidro Sdn Bhd, a company owned by Finance Ministry Incorporated, which took over the Bakun dam project from Ekran Bhd in 1997.

Thursday, March 29, 2007

Wood carriers allegedly hid 1.1 billion yen income

Kyodo News

Nine Japanese shipping companies that transport lumber from Sarawak, Malaysia, allegedly failed to report some 1.1 billion yen of income in total during a period of up to seven years through last March, sources said Wednesday, alleging the money constituted kickbacks to Sarawak officials via a Hong Kong agent.

Such tax irregularities have occurred as the Tokyo Regional Taxation Bureau determined the companies' remuneration payments to Regent Star, a Hong Kong agent, which has a connection with Chief Minister of Sarawak Taib Mahmud and his family, were rebates, not legitimate expenses, the sources said.

Although the Hong Kong agency did very little in the way of substantive work, the shipping companies are believed to have used rebates as a lubricant to facilitate their lumber trade, the sources added.

Lumber export is controlled by the Sarawak state government on grounds of forest resources protection.

Rejecting the tax authorities' conclusion, the shipping firms claim the transactions with Regent Star have been legitimate and deny wrongdoing.

The companies accused of the alleged tax evasion include Mitsui O.S.K. Kinkai Ltd. and NYK-Hinode Line Ltd. belonging to the Nanyozai Freight Agreement (NFA), a cartel formed in 1962 to avoid excessive competition in import of lumber from Southeast Asia. The 12-member group is exempt from the Antimonopoly Law.

The shipping firms will likely be slapped with well over 400 million yen in back taxes along with heavy penalties, the sources added.

According to NFA and other sources, the Japanese cartel concluded an agreement in 1981 with Malaysia's Dewaniaga Sarawak regarding lumber transport. Dewaniaga is a state-affiliated concern in charge of lumber export control and is headed by the Sarawak chief minister's younger brother.

1st Silicon (M) Sdn Bhd - concept of "transparency and accountability" doubted

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Speech

- on the debate on the second reading of the Government Investment (Amendment) Bill 2005

by Chong Chieng Jen
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

(Dewan Rakyat, Thursday): The principal Act (Government Investment Act 1983 [Act 275]) provides for the raising of funds by the Government of Malaysia for such period of time and payment of interest on the fund so raised. This Amendment Act seeks to provide for the raising of funds by the Government of Malaysia in accordance with the Syariah principles.

What I would discuss in my debate will not concern with the manner in which these funds are raised but rather the purpose and usages of the fund so raised, in what projects will these funds be invested by the Government. Funds raised by Government must be repaid in future. If the funds were not used wisely and the investments made with the funds incurred huge losses, then the Government will have to use public funds to repay these indebtedness.

Therefore, when we talk about investment by the Government, the most important things are "transparency and accountability" because we are talking about the management of public funds. The people in general has a right to know what has become of the funds used by the Government in various investments and whether these investments yield returns or suffer losses.

In Malaysia, it seems that the concept of "transparency and accountability" is not well understood or practised by the Barisan Nasional government. Since 1980s, financial scandals, one after another, were revealed but yet nobody seemed to be taking any responsibility for such mismanagement of fund. When the EPF is paying an all-time low dividend to the contributors, it is a shame that our government could still claim that it is doing well. Worst of all, despite such poor dividend return, the investment portfolio of EPF and the decision-making process in respect of the investments made by EPF are not explained to the people

Early this year, the Sarawak Government raised a fund of USD350 million through the issuance of trust certificates called "Sukuk", a bond issued by the Sarawak Government in accordance with the Syariah principles. The fund will be injected into one of the subsidiaries of the Sarawak Economic Development Corporation (SEDC) which is a statutory body incorporated by the Sarawak Government to spearhead the economic development in Sarawak.

The beneficiary company of this USD350 million fund is the company the Government labeled as "the brainchild of Sarawak" but one which I would label as "the Prodigal Son of Sarawak". The said company is 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd.

1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd is a semi-conductor wafer foundry founded by the Sarawak Government in 1998. Its major shareholder is SEDC who holds approximately 70% of the total shareholding in 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd.

From a company search conducted with the Suruhanjaya Syarikat Malaysia, it is revealed that 1st Silicon has a total paid up capital of RM1.827 billion out of which RM1.291 billion belongs to SEDC, RM421 million belongs to Sovereign Capital Berhad and the remaining RM160 millions belongs to private parties.

LIABILITIES of 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd

Beside having a large equity base of RM1.874 billion, 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd has, since its inception, not stopped raising huge loans from international financial institutions. I have with me a list of news releases by 1st Silicon itself regarding the number of loans raised by it over the years.

· In March 1999, 1st Silicon obtained a Syndicated Loan of USD 200 million from Export Credit Agency of the Federal Republic of German.

In May, 2000, it obtained a Syndicated Loan of USD 80 million from US Export Import Bank.

In July, 2000, it obtained a Syndicated Loan of USD 180 million from Noruma International plc.

In August, 2000, it obtained a loan of USD 59.5 million from Japan Bank for International Cooperation.

In December, 2000, it obtained a Syndicated Loan of USD 93.75 million from Standard Chartered Bank.

In June, 2001, it obtained a Syndicated Loan of USD 250 million from Noruma International plc.

In October, 2002, it received a new round of financing totaling USD 614 million in equity and credit. Out of the said sum of USD 614 million, USD 290 million was additional equity raised since January, 2002. The remaining USD 324 million was by way of loan of USD 120 million from Japan Bank for International Cooperation and related commercial banks and USD 204 million from US Export Import Bank.

In December, 2004, the Government of Sarawak issued 5-year Islamic bond to raise a sum of USD 350 million for injection into 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd.

From the above figures, it is shown that a total credit facility of USD 1,537.25 million was raised by 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd since its inception, not including the equity participation by the Sarawak State government into the company.

Most importantly, all these loans are guaranteed by Sarawak Government.

PERFORMANCE OF 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd

With such great sum of loan facility and equity participation by the Sarawak Government, we must be concerned about the performance of the company and the prospect of this company.

The Income Statement of the Company showed that the company has been making huge losses since its operation. The Company's 1998 account did not show any profit and loss and I could not obtain copies of the Company's 1999 account statement from the Suruhanjaya Syarikat Malaysia. However, I can show this August House that the astronomical losses of this company since the year 2000.

In the year 2000, the Company suffered a loss of RM74 million.

In the year 2001, the Company suffered a loss of RM809 million.

In the year 2002, the Company suffered a loss of RM881 million.

In the year 2003, the Company suffered a loss of RM727 million.

The loss of 1st Silicion (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd in the year 2003 alone is great than the total allocation of fund for the development of roads and bridges in Sarawak under the 2005 Budget which is only RM627.34 million.

Since the incorporation of the company in 1998 until 31-12-2003, it has suffered a loss in the total sum of RM2.5 billion. This figure is great than the total fund allocated for the development of roads and bridges in Sarawak under the 5-year 8th Malaysia Plan (2001 – 2005) which is only RM2.45 billion.

FEASIBILITY AND ECONOMIC VIABILITY of 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd

To see whether the investment in 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd is feasible and economically viable, one has also to look at company's account in terms of its revenue and cost of sales. Cost of sale are costs incurred in order to produce. If cost of sales is less than the revenue, than there is still some viability in the project, but if cost of sale is greater than the revenue, than there is no viability and future in the project at all.

For the year 2002, the revenue of 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd was RM113 million and its cost of sale is RM505 million.

For the year 2003, the revenue of 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd was RM170 million and its cost of sale is RM550 million.

In general, the ratio of cost of sale to revenue of 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd is 4 to 1. This means that for 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd, to earn RM1, it has to spend RM4. The more products it sells, 4 times more than the revenue has to be spent.

There is no future for this project and it ought to be stopped.

In answer to a question by a Member of Parliament from Barisan Nasional asking that if there is no viability in the project, why 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd can raise so much loan internationally and that the latest Sukuk loan has a high rating from the international firm Standard and Poor, my reply is that 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd was able to raise loan because of the guarantee by Sarawak Government and the high rating on Sukuk trust certificate is because it is guaranteed by the Sarawak Government, not because of the performance of 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd.

TECHNOLOGY APPLIED by 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd

In terms of advancement of technology, 1st Silicon is also generations behind its competitors worldwide. 1st Silicon is still producing wafer by using 0.25 micron technology process. On the other hand, its contemporary in West Malaysia is producing wafer by using 0.15 micron technology process and will be producing wafer by using 0.13 micron technology process in this year.

Worldwide, in Taiwan and United States, the foundries are experimenting on 0.09 micron technology process.

From 0.25 micron technology, there are 0.22 micron technology, 0.18 micron technology, 0.15 micron technology, 0.13 micron technology. It is clear that the technology employed by 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd is few generations behind the latest technology.

GOVERNMENT AUDIT REPORT

The Ketua Audit Negara, entrusted with the responsibility to audit the management of public fund by the government or its investment body, has failed in its duty in failing to highlight and include the financial position of 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd in its 2003 Audit Report on Sarawak Government.

The loss incurred by 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd for the year 2003 is RM727 million. This is definitely a material financial information which ought to be highlighted by the Ketua Audit Negara in its audit of Sarawak Government for the year 2003.

If such a glaring loss in the accounts of a subsidiary of a statutory body cannot be picked up by the Audit Department, what control measures and confidence can we have to ensure that the investment made by the Minister is proper and gives reasonable return. Not only did the Ketua Audit Negara failed in its duty to detect and highlight the astronomical losses of 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd, but in its general statement, it claims that the general financial management of Sarawak Government is good.

In the whole audit report of the Sarawak Government, there is no single word mentioned about 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd. It only mentions that the income of SEDC for the year of 2003 is RM58.28 million whereas its expenses is RM26.03 million. Where has the figure of RM727 million loss of 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd gone? Under proper accounting practices, the accounts of a subsidiary must be consolidated into the group account of the holding company. SEDC, being a holding company of 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd, must include in its yearly reports, the financial statements of 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd.

Besides 1st Silicon (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd, what are the other investments made by SEDC and whether they yield positive returns or losses. I hope in the audit report for year 2004, the Ketua Audit Negara can furnish the whole list of SEDC investment so that the Parliament can better perform its duty in holding the executive accountable.

The Ministry should not only know how to seek the approval from the Parliament to allow him to raise funds, but should also be answerable to the Parliament in the manner in which the funds so raised are used.

(28/4/2005)

* Chong Chieng Jen, DAP Member of Parliament for Bandar Kuching

There are many more cases of clear corruption , but it's too many and tedious to list them all out here.

If some of you are still sleeping, wake up.

If you have not done much for the people and will not do much for the people, resign today !

Penans Are Only Human And They Are Being Terrorised By Taib's Occupation Forces


Penans not 'noble savages' but our fellow (human) beings

By Sim Kwang Yang

malaysiakini.com

2008-10-10 | The political, cultural, and journalistic climate in Malaysia has improved after all, and the long suffering Penans begin to attract national attention.

While I was the sole opposition MP in Sarawak, I began to take on the lonely cause of fighting for the indigenous people of my homeland. There was massive infringement then of their land rights, first from loggers, and then from the plantations.

No newspaper in Sarawak dared carry any of the news and press statements because of their fear of Chief Minister Abdul Taib Mahmud. He was and still is the big patron behind the loggers, the plantation companies, and most other big businesses, including those that owned the newspapers.

The national press was also not in the least interested in this issue for reasons best known to themselves. Massive numbers of the native people in Sarawak suffered untold misery of dislocation and marginalisation in silence for decades.

In sharp contrast, when I toured Europe to lobby for the anti-logging platform in the early 90s, including an appearance in the European Parliament, I discovered to my delight that the plight of the Penans was the cause celebre for the green politicians and NGOs there.

I had to conclude that foreigners had more empathy with my indigenous brethrens in Sarawak than Sarawakians and Malaysians elsewhere. My fellow citizens in my own country - especially those in the urban centres – were too obsessed with the issue of race to develop their ultimate concern for citizens of other ethnic origins.

Journalists at their best

That was nearly two decades ago. Things must have changed since then, with no small thanks to the advent of the alternative media. Leading the pack of alternative journalists, are the brave souls in Malaysiakini finally giving the indigenous people of Sarawak a persistent voice emitting from their forgotten jungle. It is inevitable that this new found voice of conscience should find its way into the national media as well.

The work of Hilary Chiew and her presumably young colleagues in the Star belong to the type of journalists after my own heart. Thanks to them, the story of the rape of Penan girls in the heart of Sarawak’s forests has come alive for millions of Malaysians, pictures and all. That type of journalism that I had dreamed of two decades ago has arrived. The Star, despite its MCA ownership, is still much more than totally useless. I salute the editors.

What is even more gratifying is the analysis given by Jules Ong in Malaysiakini entitled Occupation and terrorism, at home. It is a wonderful critique of the 36-minute documentary made by Hilary Chiew and Chi Too entitled What rainforest? That film had its debut showing at the 2008 Freedom Film Festival recently.

I have not watched this film, but I am familiar with the issue. That is why I appreciate Jules Ong’s contribution to the debate.

The beginning of his review reminds me of Foucault’s postmodern criticism of the act of naming and categorisation as an exercise of power that often distorts the truth. The categorisation of What rainforest? as an “environmental” documentary is objectionable because, in Jules Ong’s words:

“As environmental issues become mainstream, its messages becomes simplified and stereotyped…. and boring. Add the indigenous people, and the Hollywood theme of Guardian of the Rainforest gets even more tiresome.”

Environmental protection has become a vogue now, with government powers leading the discourse. You know how it is. Recycle your newspapers, and save the world; your disquiet about your environmental footprint will be appeased. In the consciousness of many people, the environment is never going to be a bigger issue than the problem of race-relations, so why should the media give it prominence indeed.

Jules Ong has offered his own angle of looking at the issue of the indigenous people of Sarawak. He sees the loggers’ infringement of the Sarawak natives’ customary land rights and the subsequent victimisation of the local inhabitants as an act of occupation and terrorism. Unlike that occupation and terrorism of the Israeli forces in Palestine, the source of this occupation and terrorism inflicted on the Penans is home grown.

This interpretation is novel, and fits into a certain variation of the Subaltern Theory often bandied about in postcolonial discourse.

Oppressed minority groups

Homi Bhabha gave his working definition of subaltern groups as “oppressed minority groups whose presence was crucial to the self-definition of the majority group; subaltern social groups were also in a position to subvert the authority of those who had hegemonic power.”

In the context of Sarawak, that hegemonic power is in the hands of the economic-political elite that have replaced the former British colonial masters after independence, only to emerge as the post-colonial colonial masters to the indigenous people in the Land of the Hornbill.

This core of political class has cast a wide network of cronies, subordinates, and various subservient interest groups throughout the state. Sitting at the apex of this food chain, is the Chief Minister operating almost as an absolute dictator in all things Sarawakian.

The CM claims to be elected by majority acclaim, but even in the name of the majority, he still requires the poor undeveloped and “primitive” indigenous Sarawakians for his self definition. In the name of bringing development to these groups, he earns the moral authority of ruling the state in ways more sweeping than the three white Rajahs put together in a hundred years

The reality is much more stark. This ruling class groups have been using their political control to wrest fabulous wealth from this resource rich state - anything that falls under the jurisdiction of the state government, all the land, forests, minerals, and now hydropower. This ill-gotten wealth has entrenched their hold on power; during every state general election, cash flood the remotest longhouses and kampongs.

Since this ruling class has the cultural hegemony of monopolising all channels of public discourse, the indigenous people have become the silent, faceless, passive recipients of the daily harangue that issue froth from Kuching, Sibu, Bintulu, and Miri. Worse still, their human subjectivity has been stripped, since in the eyes of the post-colonial colonial masters, there are mere objects of administrative and political measures. They have become subaltern groups.

Subaltern groups are also given all kinds of derogative names, to make them sub-human. The towns Chinese in Sarawak call the Dayaks “lakia” meaning “Barbaric children”. In West Malaysia, some people call the Orang Asli “Sakai” for similar effect. When they are so named and have become subhuman, it is easier to oppress, bully and even rape them. It is certainly easier to keep a blind eye to their sufferings.

Penans not 'noble savages'

Whenever logging or plantation interests invade the land used by the indigenous people for their daily survival for many generations, there was little recourse for the native people to seek justice. The police, the media, the government machinery, and even the court are superstructure for furthering the interests of state sponsored capitalism. The Penans have borne the brunt of this invasion, because they live where the timber resources are the richest, because they are only 12,000 in number, and because they are so far removed from “civilisation” that it is difficult for social agents of change to reach them.

But the Penans’ problems – including the rape of Penan girls – are not isolated problems of an isolated ethnic community. As a subaltern group, they share the same fate as all subaltern groups in Malaysia, like the members and supporters of Hindraf, the exploited underpaid salaried workers in towns and cities, the disenfranchised farmers and fishermen across he land, and yes, the helpless conscientious idealistic reporters and journalists seeking a living in the culture industry.

A single thread runs through the life of the Penans and other subaltern groups: the half-century old political culture of soft authoritarianism, corruption, abuse of power by those who claim the support of the majority while feathering their own nests.

The 33 NGOs that had formed an alliance in support of the Penans’ cause is a noble phenomenon. Increasingly the civil society groups have to work together across the boundaries of race, gender, and agenda in recognition of their common goal: to debunk manufactured myth and to dismantle the structures of orthodox cultures for their own liberation and the self-liberation of all subaltern groups – including the Penans.

The Penans are neither Rousseau’s “noble savages” nor Hollywood’s exotic “guardians of the forests” in essence. They are fellow Malaysians and fellow human beings.

John Dun said it best in 1624:

"No man is an island, entire of itself; every man is a piece of the continent, a part of the main. If a clod be washed away by the sea,

Europe is the less, as well as if a promontory were, as well as if a manor of thy friend's or of thine own were: any man's death diminishes me, because I am involved in mankind, and therefore never send to know for whom the bells tolls; it tolls for thee."

SIM KWANG YANG was Bandar Kuching MP from 1982-1995

Friday, October 10, 2008

Is Taib Sarawak Or Is Sarawak Taib's?

Taib: Stop the 'lies' about Sarawak
Tony Thien | Oct 9, 08 10:55am Malaysiakini

Sarawak Chief Minister Abdul Taib Mahmud, usually cool in the face of criticism levelled at his government, has reacted badly to recent media reports about the eviction notice served to some 10,000 Kadayan-Malay villagers in Bekenu, near Miri and the alleged rape of Penan girls by logging company workers in the remote Baram area.

At a Hari Raya function in Miri on Monday, he said the reports were nothing but “lies” and demanded that the newspapers corrected them. The irate chief minister also warned that appropriate action would be taken against those who failed to apologise for the ‘false’ reports.

The Borneo Post, a leading local English daily, quoted the chief minister as saying that he regarded the media reports as acts of sabotage against the state.

“Check your information or you will be suspected by the decent people of Sarawak of trying to sabotage us when we have toiled to develop our state,” Taib said, in an apparent reference to reports published last week in both the Star and New Straits Times on the two issues.

Apart from The Borneo Post, several local Chinese dailies also published similar reports.

Local and national papers reported that a large group of Kadayan-Malay land-owners staged a ‘friendly protest’ after a legal firm, acting for a plantation company, last week issued notices seeking to evict them from their ancestral land which is now part of a provisional land lease issued to the company by the state government.

The company is said to be linked to a prominent Chinese businessman with powerful political connections in the state.

An Orang Ulu lawyer acting for some of the aggrieved native customary rights (NCR) landowners told Malaysiakini today that the case has been filed and will be heard in court soon.

Irate chief minister

Taib’s initial reaction to the reports on the protest by the Kadayan-Malay landowners surprised many as he was quoted by local newspapers as saying then that if the land-owners wanted to play rough with him, he was ready to do the same with them, adding that whether they liked it or not, here in Sarawak “I am the government”.

It was initially reported that the chief minister would hold a dialogue with the landowners but yesterday the chief minister changed his mind and instead dispatched his Assistant Land Minister Naroden Majais to meet representatives of the Kadayan-Malay community, led by Pemanca Abu Bakar Pangis, to find ways to resolve the land dispute.

After the meeting, the assistant minister told reporters that the villagers and the Land and Survey Department would carry out a joint survey to determine the location of the NCR land in relation to the leased land. The land lease covers about 5,000 acres and is prime agricultural land.

At another function in Betong yesterday, Taib again lashed out at the newspaper reports, calling them “acts of sabotage” which Sarawakians should ignore as they were written by journalists who had little or no knowledge of the state.

The Borneo Post today quoted him in a front page report as saying, “I have a heavy responsibility looking after the welfare of the people and will not allow the freedom of some newspapers to disrupt our progress and racial harmony.

‘We need to protect Sarawak from some irresponsible people. To protect our political stability, we must work together,” he was reported as saying.

Shocked by ‘sheer arrogance’

Meanwhile, Sarawak PKR legal advisor See Chee How said Taib’s comments were made out of “sheer arrogance”, adding that he was shocked and disappointed with the response of Sarawak BN leaders to the issues brought up by the media.

“Any reasonable government would appreciate the efforts of journalists and newspapers who have the courage to assist in the exposure of these heinous crimes,” said See when contacted by Malaysiakini today. “But unfortunately, the Sarawak government is in a state of denial by dismissing any truth in the published reports.

See said the Sarawak government should assist and facilitate a national effort to investigate the allegations.

“We are talking about the sexual abuse of teenaged school girls,” he said referring to the alleged sexual abuse of Penan girls by logging company workers operating near Penan settlements.

See opined that one of the reasons why the victims have yet to come forward to lodge police reports could be their distrust of law enforcement agencies in Sarawak.

“I do not blame them, considering the circumstances they are in. Before any investigation was carried out, the Marudi district police chief Jonathan Jalin was already reported to be dismissing the allegations, saying that there was no evidence to support them.

“How can we expect a thorough and impartial investigation into the matter from the force in Sarawak which has already dismissed the allegations before any investigation has taken place?” he asked.

Tuesday, October 7, 2008

Property Rights Of The Poor Must Be Protected By The Law

The Nature of Poverty

Property rights help the poor even more than the rich

"Poverty is the greatest shame and scandal of our era," according to FOE. All too predictably, a good bit of the report consists of a tiresome standard-issue anti-globalization screed against "neoliberal" economic policies and evil "transnational corporations." FOE notes that policy debates over how to alleviate poverty "tend to emphasize the monetary aspect of poverty, whereas many other factors—including access to and control over natural resources and land, employment, health, nutrition, education, access to services, conflict, political power and social inclusion—also play crucial roles."

Of course, the reason that people might focus on the monetary aspect of poverty is that having a bit of ready cash tends to give one access to all those other good things, such as employment, education, and social inclusion. But never mind, let's move on.

After this initial anti-globalization throat clearing, the FOE report becomes unintentionally interesting. Much of the rest of the report offers brief case studies of poverty from around the world, often among indigenous peoples. ("Indigenous" being the preferred word to describe the least modern peoples; note that the Japanese are never described as an "indigenous people.") Why unintentionally interesting? Because FOE is so busy indicting liberal economic policies that the group completely misses the significance of one of chief reasons for why so many of the people in the report's case studies are mired in poverty. Let's go through some of FOE's cases.

In Cameroon, the Bagyeli "pygmies" have been tossed out of their traditional foraging areas, which have been turned into a national park by the government.

In Chile, the Araucaria forests of the Pehuenche people were cut down by logging companies to whom the national government sold the land.

In Malaysia, the government authorized logging, the creation of plantations and dam building on the customary lands of several Sarawak forest communities.

In Togo, local fisheries are being overfished by modern fishing fleets, leaving none for Togolese fishers.

In Russia, over the past 70 years oil and gas projects on Sakhalin Island have degraded the oceanic and freshwater fisheries of the Nivkhi people.

In Laos, the Nam Theun 2 dam project financed by the World Bank and Asian Development Bank will displace 6,000 villagers, who are being resettled on insufficient land.

In Paraguay, ranchers seized and are continuing to encroach upon the ancestral territory of the Ayoreo people.

In India, the government has never recognized nor given title to the traditional lands occupied by the Katkari people, with the result that they are vulnerable to outside land developers.

Do you see a pattern here? In many of the instances cited by FOE where poor people and natural resources are being misused or abused, there are no clear property rights. In some cases, the governments simply assert ownership and ride roughshod over the desires of the local people who were under the impression that the land was theirs. In others, corrupt national governments collude with powerful interests to seize poor peoples' lands and resources.

Amusingly, while the FOE report insists on all kinds of rights for the world's poor, including environmental, human, political, collective, legal, and women's rights, there is in the report not a single mention of the word "property," as in "property rights." While FOE is to be commended for its support for restoring stolen land to poor people around the globe, it just cannot bring itself to permit individual poor people to own land. Consequently, most of the "sustainable development" schemes endorsed by FOE involve collective ownership of land and natural resources. (By collective ownership, FOE most emphatically does not mean corporate ownership.) Collective ownership by a defined group is better than government theft, but it limits the options of the joint owners who are subject to the tyranny of generally conservative majorities who stifle entrepreneurship. Evidently, FOE would prefer that poor people sit around voting all day rather than getting rich. Think church vestries or condo association meetings.

Friends of the Earth would do well to read the work of Peruvian economist Hernando de Soto, who has minutely detailed how the lack of property rights throughout the developing world keeps billions poor. Without clear title to their land, houses, stores, and so forth, the poor cannot sell their assets or borrow against them. Since their "properties" are subject to seizure at the whim of a government bureaucrat, the poor are understandably reluctant to invest in improving them. Thus they remain poor. FOE researchers who put together the group's report are so devoted to an anti-capitalist and anti-globalization ideology that they don't notice how strongly their case studies support De Soto's larger point. The poor benefit from secure private property rights even more than the rich do.